Womans faulty bed sex fall claim rejected at High Court

Woman\s faulty bed sex fall claim rejected at High Court

Maidenhead woman catapulted from bed during sex loses damages claim

A woman left paralysed after being “catapulted” from her new bed during sex has lost her seven-figure claim for damages against the bed supplier.

Claire Busby, of Maidenhead, Berkshire, suffered a serious injury to her spine when she fell from the super king size double divan as she changed position.

The 46-year-old claimed the bed was in a “defective state” at the time of her accident and took legal action against Berkshire Bed Company, trading as Beds Are Uzzz, which supplied it.

But, rejecting her case, Judge Barry Cotter found the bed was “not defective” and that Ms Busbys fall was a “tragic accident”.

Announcing his decision on Friday, the judge said: “As a result of the matters set out above, the claim in relation to this tragic accident, which is what I find it was, a simple accident, fails.”

During the trial, the court heard that the bed was one of five delivered to Ms Busbys then home, Rosewood House in Ockwells Road, Maidenhead, in August 2013 when she was renovating the property.

Ms Busby, who used to work in the property sector, was injured a week after the beds delivery while having sex with her then partner, John Marshall.

She told the court she was kneeling in the middle of the bed performing a sex act when she decided to move position and “swung her legs” from underneath her, before lying back on the bed with her head towards the bottom end.

The judge found that two gliders, or feet, were missing from the bottom end of the bed, but concluded this was not the cause of Ms Busbys accident.

He said a “much more likely cause” for the fall was that she was in an “unusual position” towards the foot of the bed and kneeling back on her feet.

Judge Cotter said she had no means of support, other than placing her arm down on the bed, as she attempted to swing her legs around from underneath her in what was “not an easy manoeuvre”.

He added: “Having carefully considered the totality of the evidence I am not satisfied that the difference in level between the two divans played any part in Ms Busbys loss of balance backwards.

“Rather, I am satisfied that this was a simple but tragic fall; she simply overbalanced probably in part because she was sitting on a mattress as opposed to a firm surface, and underestimated the amount of give underneath her body.”

Richard Manders, director of Berkshire Bed Company, said: “We are delighted the court has ruled in our favour.

Claire Busby, of Maidenhead, Berkshire, suffered a serious injury to her spine when she fell from the super king size double divan as she changed position.

The 46-year-old claimed the bed was in a "defective state" at the time of her accident and took legal action against Berkshire Bed Company, trading as Beds Are Uzzz, which supplied it.

But, rejecting her case, Judge Barry Cotter found the bed was "not defective" and that Ms Busbys fall was a "tragic accident".

Announcing his decision on Friday, the judge said: "As a result of the matters set out above, the claim in relation to this tragic accident, which is what I find it was, a simple accident, fails."

The judge said he was not satisfied the bed was "defective", even taking into account "reasonably foreseeable misuse".

He added: "It required a most unfortunate and unusual combination of positioning on the bed and movement which I do not believe would have been foreseeable by any reasonable person prior to the incident."

During the trial, the court heard that the bed was one of five delivered to Ms Busbys then home, Rosewood House in Ockwells Road, Maidenhead, in August 2013 when she was renovating the property.

Ms Busby, who used to work in the property sector, was injured a week after the beds delivery while having sex with her then partner, John Marshall.

She told the court she was kneeling in the middle of the bed performing a sex act when she decided to move position and "swung her legs" from underneath her, before lying back on the bed with her head towards the bottom end.

Richard Manders, director of Berkshire Bed Company, said: "We are delighted the court has ruled in our favour.

"We are sorry that Ms Busby was injured and we wish her and her family well for the future."

More news:

Couple and their 2 children found dead at scene of Colts Neck mansion fire
Couple and their 2 children found dead at scene of Colts Neck mansion fire
Pressure on Interpol grows as the agency considers making a Russian its chief
Pressure on Interpol grows as the agency considers making a Russian its chief
Olivier Giroud secures victory for France against Uruguay, Scotland clinch Nations League promotion
Olivier Giroud secures victory for France against Uruguay, Scotland clinch Nations League promotion
Tories will be stuck with May for the next general election unless we act now warns Rees-Mogg
Tories will be stuck with May for the next general election unless we act now warns Rees-Mogg
BBC says channels may close without over-75s licence fee
BBC says channels may close without over-75s licence fee
William reveals traumatic incident sent him over the edge while working for the air ambulance
William reveals traumatic incident sent him over the edge while working for the air ambulance
Trumps Saudi support highlights brutality of America First doctrine
Trumps Saudi support highlights brutality of America First doctrine
Cheryl hits back at abuse over X Factor performance
Cheryl hits back at abuse over X Factor performance
Anne Hegerty experiences Bush Tucker freakout on Im A Celebrity
Anne Hegerty experiences Bush Tucker freakout on Im A Celebrity
UN environment chief Erik Solheim quits amid expenses row
UN environment chief Erik Solheim quits amid expenses row
It took me over the edge: Prince William reveals heartbreak of air ambulance pilot job
It took me over the edge: Prince William reveals heartbreak of air ambulance pilot job
BBC launches consultation on free TV licences for over-75s
BBC launches consultation on free TV licences for over-75s